When summoned, Youth Pastor Craig will throw a microphone at the enemy New Kid, preventing him/her from casting spells for 30 seconds.
- "Open your heart to salvation!"
- "Open your heart-!"
- "Have you found-?"
- "My faith is shaken!"
- "Jesus, save me, fuck it!"
- This card is extremely good for pushing, as it prevents any spells that can be used against the player.
- The card can be used against smaller minions like rats or pigeons.
- Made playable.
- Added to PvP packs and PvP lockers.
- Added to free packs, main shop packs, and PVE packs.
- His warcry ability comes out really fast, so you need to have good reflexes to take him down with a spell and avoid suffering the effects of his ability.
- Youth Pastor Craig was made playable just after Imp Tweek was. This is a reference to the duo's extremely popular gay relationship on the show.
- At some point, Youth Pastor Craig's animation and quotes when summoned was shortened.